Sign up now
to enroll in courses, follow best educators, interact with the community and track your progress.
30th August 2017 Part-2: Daily News Analysis
6,016 plays

Supreme Court Article 27

Jatin Verma is teaching live on Unacademy Plus

Jatin Verma
Have appeared in UPSC CSE thrice. Have been taking Unacademy Plus courses Academics- Polity, Economics & Current Affairs.

Unacademy user
For the issue relating to top Court sets aside HC order on riot recompense, I believe that taxpayers money should not be used for the rehabilitation of destroyed religious structures as they already receive huge amounts of donations by the commoners and also they do not pay any taxes for that. Charity for floods and diseases is not as common as charity for religious purposes.Secondly if it becomes mandatory for the state governments to compensate for such damages then indirectly it will encourage such activities in the future.Giving away a huge chunk of taxpayers money for rehabilitation of religious structures is not justified as our country has a lot of other infrastructural concerns to address to on priority basis. Also houses destroyed in riots are more important than religious structures because religion is faith and faith is at the core of the heart of the individual which cannot be destroyed.
in my opinion , the honorable sc's contention that riot affected religious structures are at par with houses damaged or destroyed in the violence is correct and if this is the rationale then in case of a violence it is the responsibility of the state to reconstruct both because one is god's home and the other is his child's. but priority should be given to houses demolished . in order to fulfill it's responsibility like to complete construction work of metro ,in many cases temples have been demolished and people have supported the govt. and the path of development : govt. in return has assured to shift the temple at some other place - in that case we didn't say that the state is promoting one particular religion likewise if the executive has failed in carrying out its responsibility , the govt. should compensate , as sir said .
In my point of view this Judgement have many DIMENSIONS:----------- Societal- As people of all Religion, race and cast are part of society. In such a light there would be possibility that if one community has be compensated for destruction of Religious institutions. Some fringe element would youse as an opportunity to create communal tension. Moral- In many case it is seen that these religious institutions are involved in some kind of welfare work i.e Serving food to poor people etc. in such case it is moral responsibility of state to prove them compensation so that their activity is not disrupted. Legal- Sir that point you have well explained. It could also be used as an opportunity by STATE to fill up trust deficit among various communities. Like Donations that Temple or Church receive "with their consent" to be allocated for renovation of destroyed properties and vice-versa.
Rahul Kanwat
2 years ago
I agree with you because it is a political compition that can create violence ,opposition party may use it election agenda.
Shivam singh
2 years ago
yess brother
As seen in our society , to promote ones religion every nook and corner of the cities and town are flooded from numbers of structures, .Its better to get them insured from a private firm which are there to compensate in case of any unfortunate incidents.
Jatin Verma
2 years ago
Kalyug: Now God needs insurance against rioters....on a lighter note
Khem Raj Meena
2 years ago
Sir how I can listen your editorial past & current
Can we criticize Judiciary after it has given final verdict on any issues in our Mains answer?As we refer these verdicts to prove our answer in maximum of cases Won't it be detrimental to our marks...Please provide ur response.Experienced guys
Aneesh Menon
2 years ago
Most important thing one should be vary about while criticizing is making sure it is a "constructive criticism",whether it is of Government or Courts.If you are criticizing, then make sure you have a strong base on that topic and give practical alternative solutions which are feasible in nature.
Ohk understood..thanks Aneesh
  1. DAILY NEWS ANALYSIS from THE HINDU 30th August 2017 By JATIN VERMA Educator Unacademy For Daily The Hindu News & Editorial analysis- Visit my Unacademy profile-

  2. Page-l: Rain pounds Mumbai to standstill; no relief in sight . Urban Drainage system 2015- Chennai Floods Recent water-logging problem in Chandigarh, Gurgaon Solutions: Making the country's metropolis as 'city states,' Since these megapolises have grown many folds in all aspects of urban development they can no more be seen as cities in the traditional sense. Re-development: Is ir feasible in Countries like India? Question. Are Municipalities equipped legislatively, financially and technically to deal with waterlogging problems? . Flood control as a subject has no clear cut legislative marking.As a subject it is not included in any of the legislative lists of the country that is the Union, the State or the Concurrent lists Issues related to drainage and embankments find a mention in Entry 17 of List II of the State List. That entails that preventing and fighting floods is primarily the responsibility of the state governments Issues related to drainage and embankments find a mention in Entry 17 of List " of

  3. Radial Pattern of Development: FEATURES OF ON RADIAL PLANNING Features of radial city pattern Inner outer ring roads linked by radiating roads Core has the business area. Industrial area interspersed within the residential. Periphery has green belts.

  4. what should be done?? Advance town planning and yearly preparations should be done to mitigate the effects of urban planning. Cleaning of drains and rivulets near the cities should be accorded top priority. . Construction of embankments, flood walls, ring bunds, flood control reservoirs should be scientifically carried on. Improvement of river channels and surface drainage and most importantly checking erosion of land on river banks. The Centre-states mechanism needs to be further strengthen with focus on greater coordination. This has to be a continuous and ongoing system rather than waking up at the time of the calamity only. The Centre and the states through a joint plan should undertake various measures to control floods. Institutional Response so far: The state level set up has water resources departments, flood control board and state technical advisory committee. The Central mechanism has a network of organisations and expert committees constituted from time to time to study advice on flood management.[At best, Ad-Hoc]

  5. Page-l:'Criminalising marital rape may become a tool to harass husbands' TG.S.M. 1,2] Facts of the Matter: [ilIn India, marital rape is not defined in any statute or law. Section 375 that defines rape also says sexual intercourse by a man with his wife aged 15 years or above is not rape even if it is without her consent. Section 376B deals with sexual intercourse by man with his wife during separation. Issue: Rights activists want it to be made a criminal offence, saying it forces women to suffer the worst form of sexual violence in their homes. Petitioners NGO RIT Foundation, All India Democratic Women's Association and a marital rape victim have challenged as unconstitutional an exception to Section 375 of IPC & Section 376B The Centre's stance before Delhi High Court: [i] Criminalising marital rape may destabilise the institution of marriage and would become an easy tool for harassing husbands, a position slammed as retrograde by rights activists. [i] Supreme Court and high courts had already pointed to the misuse of Section 498A of Indian Penal Code (IPC) that prescribes punishment for husband for subjecting his wife to cruelty. [ii]As to what constitutes marital rape and what would constitute marital non-rape needs to be defined precisely before a view on its criminalisation is taken

  6. [iv]lf all sexual acts by a man with his own wife qualify to be marital rape, then the judgment as to whether it is a marital rape or not will singularly rest with the wife, adding there could be no lasting evidence of such acts between a man and his own wife. [] Defining marital rape would need a broad-based consensus and a change in the attitude of prosecutors, police officers and society in general. Petitioners' Stance before Delhi High Court: Marriage cannot be viewed as licence for a husband to rape his wife with impunity and a married woman has the same right of full control over her body as an unmarried woman. . A reference was made to Judgments of foreign countries, mostly western ones, where marital rape is criminalised To this, the Centre said it does not necessarily mean India should follow them blindly. . Counter-point by Govt:_This country has its own unique problems due to various factors like literacy, lack of financial empowerment of the majority of females, mindset of the society, vast diversity, poverty, etc. and these should be considered carefully before criminalising marital rape. Social awareness:"Moral and social awareness" plays a vital role in stopping such an act. . If all sexual acts by a man with his own wife will qualify to be marital rape, then the judgment as to whether it is marital rape or not will singularly rest with the wife

  7. Page-7:ISRO opensupsatellitemakingtoindustry [Make in India in Science or PPP in Science] The Indian Space Research Organisation has opened the door to domestic entities that can give it up to 18 spacecraft a year starting mid to late 2018 Currently, about eight satellites are being produced in a year for national programmes; a 2,000-kg spacecraft costs ISRO about?200 crore. Present bid is about AIT: The Bengaluru-based ISRO Satellite Centre (ISAC), which has so far produced about 90 Indian spacecraft, invited single or combined industries to apply for this opportunity. The centre expected to select five or six contenders from this exercise if they are found technically suitable. e Three-year contract ISAC would sign a three-year contract with the finalists, train, handhold and supervise their teams in making its range of satellites at its facility. The first lot of spacecraft from this exercise was expected in about six months from the signing of the contracts. This is also roughly the normal time taken to assemble a satellite.

  8. . The Indian Space Research Organisation currently makes four categories of spacecraft communication, remote sensing, navigation and scientific missions-and in three sizes of 1,000 kg to 4,000 kg. . The outsourcing of assembly, integration and testing [AlT] in a way covers operational spacecraft, mostly repeat types that ISRO routinely requires. About the cost of industry-made spacecraft versus those made in-house: ISRO does not envisage any cost increase The contract mentions milestone payments, assigning of new spacecraft upon delivery;and a possible renewal of contract after three years Benefits for ISRO []Right now, the manpower of ISAC/ISRO is not adequate for meeting both the increased load of making more satellites; and also for the R&D that we need for future satellites. [iilt would also aid self-reliance by way of an independent Indian satellite industry. . Long term goal is to get vendors to make satellites "end to end In the $ 339-billion global space industry, satellite manufacturing accounts for 8% or $13.9 billion ( data as per the Satellite Industry Association's 2017 report). . This segment is led by established players from the United States and Europe who supply satellites to their government and commercial users.

  9. Page-7:Top court sets aside HC order on riot recompense The Supreme Court set aside a Gujarat High Court order directing the State to pay compensation to shrines destroyed in the 2002 communal riots. The court agreed with State government that taxpayers' money cannot be spent to promote a particular religion. The court expressed satisfaction with the Gujarat government's scheme to pay up to 50,000 as ex-gratia assistance to authorised religious places damaged, destroyed or desecrated during the riots. Endorsing earlier view: A Bench of SC. said the scheme placed the riot-affected religious structures "on par" with "houses destroyed or damaged" in the violence. Supreme Court endorsed an earlier view of the Supreme Court in the Prafull Goradia judgment that using "substantial part" of the tax-payers' money for paying damages to destroyed religious structures would violate Article 27 of the Constitution Article 27 forbids the state from compelling a person to pay taxes for promotion or maintenance of any particular religion or religious denomination.

  10. Page-10: Nasheed flags presence of Chinese warships in Male The presence of three Chinese Naval warships on a five-day "goodwill visit" in the Maldives is unprecedented and could indicate Beijing's larger military presence in the Indian Ocean island nation in the future, says former Maldivian president Mohamed Nasheed. . China-Maldives friendship bridge: He said apart from the warships, it was China's growing influence in constructing major infrastructure projects including the $200 million "China Maldives friendship bridge" from Male to Hulhule island that should be viewed with some concern Strategic infrastructure often does facilitate military use. So it is very possible that President Yameen is offering China more than just infrastructure projects Maldives High Commissioner to India denied the Chinese warships represented a significant shift in Maldivian policy, citing a previous occasion in 2014, when the PLA's naval supply ship rushed to Male with fresh water supplies during a treatment plant collapse. India too had sent in tonnes of water and filtration equipment on two naval warships then. India maintains silence: Significantly, India has made no statement on the development, in contrast to the critical comments made when Chinese submarines docked in Colombo harbour in 2014

  11. o Page-10:With Doklam standoff resolved, PM to visit China A day after the resolution of the Doklam standoff, India announced that Prime Minister will pay a three-day visit to China during September 3-5, 2017 to attend the 9th BRICS Summit. . The trip is likely to include a one-on-one meeting between Prime Minister Modi and President Xi Jinping on September 4 The meeting between the two leaders will be the first since they exchanged courtesies during the July 7-8 G20 summit meeting in Hamburg. . PM's visit to China for the BRICS summit will be followed by his visit to Myanmar. Mr. Modi had hosted Ms. Suu Kyi during an outreach for the BIMSTEC on the sideline of the BRICS summit held in Goa in 2016. The visit to Myanmar comes days after India expressed concern over fights between Rohingya attackers and the Myanmar security forces. . In a strong statement issued on August 26, India extended support to the Myanmar security rces and described the attackers as "terrorists"

  12. International News: Rohingya in Bangladesh face expulsion despite UN warning Rohingya Muslims fleeing to Bangladesh from escalating violence in Myanmar face the growing danger of sickness and attempts by the Bangladesh authorities to send them home, despite a United Nations plea that they be allowed to seek shelter. . A series of coordinated attacks by Rohingya insurgents on security forces in the north of Myanmar?s Rakhine state has triggered a fresh exodus to Bangladesh of Muslim villagers trying to escape the violence.

  13. . Besides, a Task Force on Artificial Intelligence for India's Economic Transformation has also been constituted. Since the last Industrial Policy announced in 1991, India has transformed into one of the fastest growing economies in the world and is now equipped to deploy a different set of ideas and strategies to build a globally competitive Indian industry, it added. The discussion paper said the constraints to industrial growth includes [il] inadequate infrastructure, [i]restrictive labour laws, [ii]complicated business environment. [ivjslow technology adoption, [Vlow productivity, [vi]challenges for trade including the Indian MSME sector facing tough competition from cheap imports from China and FTA countri (vijnadequate expenditure on R&D and Innovation.

  14. . Further, the Bill proposes that the minimum wages so fixed by the Central government be applicable to all employments covering both organised and unorganised sector.The present law, Minimum Wages Act of 1948, applies to employees working in 45 scheduled employments. Presently: [ilvarious states are free to fix their own level of minimum wages as per the local conditions, cost of living and other factors [il Centre fixes a National Floor Level Minimum Wage - a non-statutory measure to ensure that states fix their minimum wages beyond this floor level. This is one of the reasons why the changes to the minimum wage law assumes significance as through this Bill, the minimum wages set by the Centre will become statutory. . With effect from July I this year, the Labour Ministry announced a hike in the National Floor Level Minimum Wage from 160 Per day to 76 a day and sent advisories to states for compliance. . However, till April I this year,at least II States, including Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat,Arunachal Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh, Manipur, Nagaland, Tripura and Tamil Nadu, had fixed their minimum wage level below the National Floor Level Minimum Wage of 60 recommended by the Central government as on that date.

  15. For Indian Polity Crash course, Visit my Unacademy profile-

  16. Other Courses by me: Mediumm Timings 1. The Hindu News Analysis 2. The Hindu Editorial Analysis 3. Daily PIB Summary Live Now. 4. Daily MCQs on Current Affairs 5. Yojana/Kurukshetra Analysis Coming son. [Hindi & 6. Indian Polity Crash Course 7. Most Important Current Affairs. [Hindi & English] 9.00 am [Hindi & English] 9.00 am [Hindi & English] 5.00 pm [Hindi & English]7.30 pm English] Ist Sunday [Hindi for now] [Hindi & English]. Periodic Periodic Sunday-weekly DNA Review: Sunday-weekly Editorial Review: A re-cap of Most Important News of the week A re-cap of Most useful Editorials of the week For Indian Polity Crash course, Visit my Unacademy profile-