Art of Answer Writing In Ethie Case Study 1. 2017 GS Paper 4. unacademy SHUBHAM SINGH
Question 12 (Case 6) Q9. You are an honest and responsible civil servant. You often observe the following: (a) There is a general perception that adhering to ethical conduct one may face difficulties to oneself and cause problems for the family, whereas unfair practices may help to reach the career goals (b) When the number of people adopting unfair means is large, a small minority having a penchant towards ethical means makes no difference. (c) Sticking to ethical means is detrimental to the larger developmental goals (d) While one may not involve oneself in large unethical practices, but giving and accepting small gifts makes the system more efficient. Examine the above statements with their merits and demerits. (250 Words, 20)
Fonedt-Quality being, tu, e and odherence seng erial prind ples Toking ouene1shi ones action amd being ansesile tous ngmitien and ablic ndhering to chical ceducl tike honesty innte ard impestiatitt msgiralition uichro el Caiinal and Suicide schling es kids Thus meams one con in dom Good beoks olsnless omd caress
46 meons hu oool ScaTO lstsc conscience ading to dg- l ecom dishenes huan being as ocu monl cu Thus, pcth orienceurth ge humi lated
(b) When the number of people adopting unfair means is large, a small minority having a penchant towards ethical means makes no difference. Viability and effectiveness of minority people who adhere to Ethical Principles when majority is corrupt is often questioned. Can single Individual make difference under circumstances of Systemic corruption? and often used as a valid argument for individual to be part of the system and adopt its vices. However, history have innumerable examples, where a single individual has turned the course of history and had change entire system instead of adopting its vices.
Examples: Gandhi ji, Martin Luther King, B.R Ambedkar, Abraham Lincolr fought lone battle for social reform against all odds. Julio Ribero, T.N Seshan, Prakash Singh, Satyendra Dubey, Manjunathan are few Public Servants who despite being alone, fought there battle against the ills of the system and brought about reform in the system itself. Police reform, RTI, Whistle blower act are few examples of positive outcome of the efforts of small minority who braved all odds
(c) Sticking to ethical means is detrimental to the larger developmental goals . Ethical means like. SIA, EIA, Gram Sabha consent, democratic means, transparency and objectivity in system etc. may slow down the process of development Laws like Labour regulation, CSR etc. reduces Ease of Doing Business . On the other side mechanism like Bribing, Lobbying, overlooking of Due Bribe act as grease to the wheel of administration and thus make it more Thus, end justify the means should be ethical guidance system in Process of process of development may speed up the process of development. efficient. Development
However, Unethical means adopted to achieve development, may frustrate the process in long term. Ex. Bribing may get institutionalized, leading to rent seeking behaviour. HDI and CPI (corruption Perception Index) are closely related. Overlooking SIA, EIA may have long term negative impact like Natural Disaster, climate change etc. thus reversing the process of development. Because of these factors, Gandhi ji advocated for Right means for the right end. Thus, for sustainable development, ethical means should be adopted to achieve it
(d) While one may not involve oneself in large unethical practices. but giving and accepting small gifts makes the system more efficie Nazrana/ suvidha shulka etc. are various terminology which aim to legitimize petty forms of corruption It is often argued, accepting small gifts in return of service is acceptable and part and parcel of Public services. Small gifts as goodwill gesture act as motivation for civil servant, and thus makes system more efficient by lubricating wheel of administrative machinery mt.
However, corruption is corruption and it has same negative repercussion on administration, irrespective of whether bribe is big or small Negative impact of accepting small gifts. .Rent seeking behaviour . Dilute principles of universality, objectivity and Integrity which are foundational values of Civil services. CoC lays upon strict guidelines against accepting any form of gift in return of services Spirit of service, compassion and Patriotism which makes Public services efficient and not these petty gifts.
R R 44% 6:04 AM o..a .d R R 44% 6:04 AM HINDI PREMOUS YEAR QUESTIONS (Hindi) 2018 GS 4 Complete Paper Discussion and Answer Writing-U.. Indian Map and Important Related Facts and Figures HINDI CRASH COURSE 02:45:05 (Hindi) Foundational Valuev Services 4.4 5k views 8 months ago 03 07:22 5.0 67 views 11 hours ago 49-3.8k views last month Shubham Singh 223 Shubham Singh . 21 ii Shubham Singh 203 HINDI CRASH COURSE How To Solve Quote Based Questions in Exam: UPSC HINDI FEATURES (Hindi) Confusing Facts on Indian Polity- UPSC Prelims Special HINDI THE EARTH&THE UNIVERS (Hindi) Understanding the Universe and Planet Earth for UPPSC 49 3.1k views 10 months ago ii Shubham Singh 01:39:02 04:15:08 4.9 2.8k views 6 days ago 126 48-2.9k views 5 days ago Shubham Singh 207 159 Shubham Singh HINI STRATEGY FOR PRELIMS HIND CRASH COURSE (Hindi) Crash Course on Ethical Philosophies *4.8 15.9k views 6 days ago (Hindi) Preparation Strategy to Crack HINDI MOCK TEST (Hindi) Topic 365 'Master one topic a day UPPSC 01:38:24 09-41:07 45 2.5k views 10 months ago 01:14:26 5.0 439 views 6 months ago i Shubham Singh O 81 i Shubham Singh 745 A i Shubham Singh 51 HINDI LESSONS&TEACHINGS HINDI DIMENSIONS OF ETHICS (Hindi) Understanding Key Terms of Ethics HINDI NATIONAL EVENTS (Hindi) UPPSC Current Affairs for March 4.7 382 views 7 months ago (Hindi) Current Affairs of Ethics 4.6 10.1k views last month 11:05:31 4.8 21.7k views 8 days ago 01:09:57 i Shubham Singh 497 i Shubham Singh 932
Star* and Verified Educator, Visiting Faculty @SPIPA GUJARAT and Forum IAS. completed full course of Ethics, Art & Culture, Polity.