NEET UG » NEET UG Study Material » Physics » Drawbacks Of Rutherford Model Of Atom

Drawbacks Of Rutherford Model Of Atom

This article mentions the drawbacks of Rutherford's model of the atom and the effect of his experiment on alpha scattering.

Rutherford tested to decide the dissemination of electrons and positive charges, yet there are a few disadvantages that we concentrate on exhaustively. To comprehend this, we will discuss how Rutherford proposed the model in which adversely charged electrons encompass the atoms core. Furthermore, this model adversely charges electrons, and the nucleus is thickly focused.

Physicists first observed that alpha particles radiating through an opening onto a visual plate would make a sharp-edged picture. Ernest Rutherford introduced the most classical model. Rutherford’s model proposed that the charge on the core was the main trait of the molecule, deciding its construction.

Background of Rutherford Model of Atom

The Rutherford Atomic model, otherwise called the Rutherford model, atomic molecule, or planetary model of the particle, was laid out in 1911, which made sense of the construction of atoms and was created by the New Zealand-conceived physicist Ernest Rutherford. The model determined that the atom is only a tiny thick mass with a charged body in the center, known as the core or nucleus. The molecule’s mass is concentrated, and the adversely charged light electrons rotate around it at a specific distance, similar to the planets spinning around the sun.

In the gold foil explorer, the core was hypothesized as a thick and small mass that was answerable for dispersing the alpha particles. The Rutherford model was an extension of the nuclear model developed by Sir J.J. Thomson, explaining how electrons are inserted into a nucleus and how they interact with protons and neutrons like plums in a custard.

Bhor’s nuclear model obsoleted Rutherford’s model. Bohr’s atomic model is believed to integrate a portion of the early ideas of the quantum hypothesis.

Rutherford Experiment on Alpha Scattering

Rutherford led a light dissipating test where he put a gold foil and assaulted the gold sheet with the alpha particles. The direction of the alpha particles concentrated after they communicated with the gold foil. A radioactive source produced Alpha particles, which are decidedly charged particles encased inside a lead safeguard defensively.

The radiation then passed in a thin pillar after it went through a cut ahead of the pack screen. An exceptionally dainty segment of a gold foil is set before the lead screen. Zinc sulfide covered the LED screen to give it a fluorescent nature and filled in as a counter location to the Alpha particles.

When the Alpha particles in a particle accelerator collide with each other, they create an explosion of light known as a glimmer – and it is this explosion that gives the device’s output its distinctive color. The result was apparent from the magnifying survey instrument. As the screen was versatile, Rutherford concluded that the Alpha particles got diverted by the gold foil.

Perceptions of Rutherford’s Alpha Scattering Experiment

The perception that Rutherford made let him presume that:

  1. By far most of the Alpha particles that flooded the gold fell proceeded with no evasion, which shows that the core comprises a vast void space.
  2. Not many of the Alpha particles that assaulted the gold foil encountered a minor diversion that showed a presence of a counter charge.
  3. A portion of the Alpha particles that assaulted the gold foil was redirected to a more significant point. Some even returned, showing that the positive charge is packed in a tiny volume, and its dispersion is non-uniform.

All the above focuses show that the volume involved by emphatically charged particles in an atom is tiny when contrasted with the complete volume of the molecule.

The consequence of Rutherford’s Alpha Scattering Experiment

Based on his investigation, perception, and result, Rutherford set forward Rutherford’s nuclear model, which had the accompanying elements:

  1. The whole mass and positive charge are amassed in a tiny district known as the core in the middle.
  2. The positive charge on the core is because of protons. Since the quantity of protons is different for particles of various components, the extent of positive charge on the nucleus is different for atoms of multiple parts.
  3. Adversely charged electrons encircle the core. The quantity of electrons in a molecule is equivalent to the number of protons (decidedly assigned) in the nucleus. Subsequently, the atom, all in all, is unbiased.
  4. The electrons are spinning around the core at a fast rate.
  5. The vast majority of a molecule’s space is unoccupied.

Disadvantages or Drawbacks of Rutherford’s Atomic Model

  1. This nuclear model neglected to make sense of the steadiness of molecules.
  2. Electrons, as shown by the model, rotate at a constant speed around the nucleus rather than being retained in a steady state as we do today.
  3. This model of the particle additionally neglected to make sense of the presence of clear lines in the hydrogen range.

Conclusion

Physicists had previously observed that alpha particles radiated through an opening onto a visual plate would make a sharp-edged picture. In contrast, alpha particles in mica would establish a connection with hazy edges. Rutherford toppled Thomson’s model in 1911 with his renowned gold-foil analysis, in which he demonstrated that the particle has a small, gigantic core. Most alpha particles went straight through the foil, yet the foil avoided some.

faq

Frequently asked questions

Get answers to the most common queries related to the NEET UG Examination Preparation.

What is Rutherford's experiment? When did Rutherford win a Nobel Prize for discovering the atom's nucleus?

Ans. Rutherford and his students experimented with a thin gold foil with high...Read full

What did Rutherford observe during his experiments?

Ans. When the alpha particle is bombarded with the thin gold foil, Rutherford observed that most of the space in th...Read full

What are the main consequences of Rutherford's Alpha Scattering Experiment?

Ans. The positive charge on the core is because of protons. Since the quantity of protons is different for particles...Read full

What are the drawbacks of the Rutherford model of atoms?

Ans. The Rutherford model does not give information about how stable the atom is. As per the Rutherford model, the e...Read full