Sign up now
to enroll in courses, follow best educators, interact with the community and track your progress.
Download
Weekly Special Series: Surrogacy Bill then, and now (in Hindi)
940 plays

More
Difference between the Surrogacy Bill Draft(2016) and Bill Passed (2018) in Lok Sabha in current Winter session. The lesson also explains what recommendations of the Standing Committee were not taken into account while the passage of the bill

Rishab Arora
Graduate in Economics. Gold medal in Dissertation, Prepared various documents on Demonetisation and GST, Share-trading and many more

U
Unacademy user
though our govt has banned commercial surrogacy but should it be allowed with a proper regulatory mechanism and authority as it can b a source of livelihood for poor women who are willing to be a surrogate mother???
  1. SURROGACY BILL, THEN & NOW


  2. ON WEDNESDAY, Lok Sabha passed the Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, 2016. Cleared by the Cabinet in 2016, the Bill was subsequently referred to a Parliamentary Standing Committee (Health & Family Welfare) before its passage. A look at its journey, the issues raised along the way, and which of these it addresses and which of these it does not: What does the Bill aim to do? . Drafted keeping in mind the "Indian ethos"words used both by Health Minister J P Nadda in Parliament Wednesday and External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj in 2016 when she announced that the Bill had been cleared by the Cabinetthe Bill allows only altruistic surrogacy (by relatives) for married couples. " It seeks to put an end to commercial surrogacy payment to a surrogate mother is punishable by up to five uitin against sex selecon years imprisonment and also has safeguards built in against sex selection of the baby.The Bill proposes to allow altruistic, ethical surrogacy to intending infertile Indian married couples between the ages of 23-50 (female) and 26-55 (male). It limits the option to only legally married childless couples who have been trying for a child for at least five years.The commissioning couple cannot have a surviving child either biological or adopted, except when they have a child who is mentally or physically challenged or suffers from a life-threatening disorder with no permanent cure. the banhe ages of 23-50 (fee


  3. Why was the Bill necessary? There have been several reports about the exploitation of surrogate mothers, women who are kept confined in "hostels" during pregnancy and not allowed to meet their families, women who do it repeatedly for a paltry amount thus putting their own bodies at risk. - The Bill seeks to put an end to that. Ballpark estimations by Indian Council of Medical Research are around 2,000-odd babies per year through commercial surrogacy when a woman is paid a pre-fixed sum for renting her womb. Cll figures say surrogacy is a $2.3 billion industry fed by lack of regulation and poverty. . The 228th report of the Law Commission had recommended prohibition of commercial surrogacy. Commercial surrogacy is allowed only in Russia, Ukraine and California. The Bill now requires all surrogacy clinics to be registered. Clinics can charge for these services but the surrogate mother cannot be paid. The national and state surrogacy boards will be the regulating authorities. -


  4. 2016 BILL, 2018 AMENDMENTS The provisions of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, 2016, and the amendments proposed in2018 SOURCE- THE INDIAN EXPRESS CON SENT 20161 Surrogacycannot be initiatecd unlcssall side effectsexplainedtothe surrogatemother,and unlessshehas venwritten informmedconscnt 181 New.She hasoption to withdrawbeforeembryo inplanted PROHIBITED 20161 Forsurrogacy dinics and doctors, Bill prohibits: Forsurrogacycdinics anddoctors, Bill prohibitscommercial surrogacy: cmploying unqualificd persons: storinghuman embryo,ctc 2018] Any formofsexselection for surrogacy,too,will beprohibited CR Sasikmar INSURANCE ELIGIBILITY 20161 Couple necdsa certificate of essentiality'.conditionalto insurance 2016I Surrogate mothermust bea rage for surrogatemother close relativeofintending couple,an ever marriedwoman withachiklof 2018I Coveragewill haveto be her own: must be aged 25-35: must provicled for 16 monthscovcring not havebeen asurrogate mother earlier; reuirescertificate of dical and psychoogical fitess postpartumddiverycomplications AUTHORISATION TIME PERIOD 2018| New provision:Surrogate mothercannot provideherown gametes for surrogacy 20181 90-day limit toauthoritiesfor grantingor rejectingapplicationsfor variouscertificatesard authorisations


  5. What maternity benefits would a commissioning mother be entitled to? The Bill does not take that into account. It deals with the rights and responsibilities of commissioning parents and surrogate mother vis a vis each other and the baby, but does not address entitlements of a commissioning parent from his or her employer.These are covered by labour laws; the law on maternity benefits does not take into account the possibility of a woman becoming a mother without actually giving birth . Is the Bill newly passed different from the one cleared by the Cabinet in 2016? There are changes, including a reduction of punishment. The earlier version provided for a minimum jail term of 10 years for some offences, the present one sets a maximum of 10 years. The present Bill forbids the surrogate mother to use her own gametes (eggs), gives her the option to withdraw before the embryo is implanted, and puts a condition for obtaining a "certificate of essentiality" that the intending couple needs-they must provide a 16-month insurance coverage for the surrogate mother including postpartum complications. The Bill did not make several changes sought by the Standing Committee *


  6. OFFENCES AND PENALTIES 2016I (i)Forviolations, minujail 2018 I (i)Min imum term of 5 years term5 years, fine up to Rs10 lakh (ii) For initiating commercial surgery, (ii) Minimum term of5 years replaced minimum 5 years, fine up to Rs 10 lakh with maximum term of 5years replacedwith maximum of 5 years (ii) For contravening any provision for ii)Minimum jail term of3 years which no punishment not specified, replaced with maximum termof 3 minimum3 years, fine upto Rs 5lakh years (iv) Forcertain offences including iv)Minimum jail term of 10 years exploitation, importing of embryo, replacedwith maximum 10 years minimum 10 yrs, fine up to Rs 10 lakh Source: Edited from PRS Legislative Research SOURCE- The INDIAN EXPRESS


  7. What were these recommendations? Pointing out that the Supreme Court has recognised live-in relationships, the Standing Committee had recommended that the government "broadbase the eligibility criteria in this regard and widen the ambit of persons who can avail surrogacy services by including live-in couples, divorced women/ widows". It - penosealtruistic surragacy o altruistic should be replaced with had countered the "altruistic surrogacy for married couples" argument and recommended that compensation be the norm and the word altruistic should be replaced with compensated. Altruistic surrogacy, it observed, is tantamount to exploitation "Permitting women to provide reproductive labour for free to another person but preventing them from being paid for their reproductive labour is grossly unfair and arbitrary...altruistic surrogacy is another extreme and entails high expectations from a woman willing to become a surrogate without any compensation or reward but a decision based on noble intentions and kindness," the report said.